Request 1087396 (accepted)

This request supersedes: request 757472 (Show diff), request 895776 (Show diff)

Overview

Request 1087396 accepted

Hi, this is the hawk2 that we use in our HA.

Created by aburlakov about 1 year ago
In state accepted
Supersedes 757472 895776

Submit hawk2

Comments for request 1087396 11

Aleksei Burlakov (aburlakov) - about 1 year ago

author source maintainer

Hi, you may find that the submission request superseeds the 757472 and 895776. It's ok. Why is it so? The short answer is, the old hawk is bad, the new one is good. But why the old is bad? It doesn't work, it's never been in production, and it's hopelessly obsolete and diverged. And what is good about the new hawk? In short, It works and it's green. It's basically the healthy master branch that we use in sle15 and leap15. I made the least changes to enable it in tumbleweed.

Dominique Leuenberger (dimstar) - about 1 year ago

reviewer

+Obsoletes:      hawk <= 1.1.0
+Provides:       hawk = %{version}

why not simply replace / update the actual hawk package then and call this one hawk2?

Aleksei Burlakov (aburlakov) - about 1 year ago

author source maintainer

I wanted to make as few changes in the stable hawk as possible. I took as a base the same file as https://build.opensuse.org/package/view_file/openSUSE:Leap:15.5:Update/hawk2/hawk2.spec?expand=1 and added the necessary changed. How would you propose to change it technically?

Dominique Leuenberger (dimstar) - about 1 year ago

reviewer

additional issue detected:

can't install hawk2-2.6.4+git.1682509819.1ff135ea-1.1.x86_64:
nothing provides hawk-apiserver needed by hawk2-2.6.4+git.1682509819.1ff135ea.x86_64

Aleksei Burlakov (aburlakov) - about 1 year ago

author source maintainer

Yap, I have created another request https://build.opensuse.org/request/show/1087554

Aleksei Burlakov (aburlakov) - about 1 year ago

author source maintainer

@dimstar let's merge it?)

Dominique Leuenberger (dimstar) - about 1 year ago

reviewer

I still think this should be called hawk, not hawk2. It is only a continuation and version upgrade, not a fork

Aleksei Burlakov (aburlakov) - about 1 year ago

author source maintainer

@dimstar, it's a fair point, it's just that the hawk has always and everywhere been the hawk2 , (for example here https://build.opensuse.org/package/show/openSUSE:Leap:15.0:Update/hawk2 or here https://build.suse.de/package/show/SUSE:SLE-15:GA/hawk2 or anywhere)

Jan Engelhardt (jengelh) - about 1 year ago

reviewer

hawk2 was created under ambiguous rules in 2015 (so, there's the reason to grant an exception to package naming)
hawk2 was deleted from Factory in 2021 (and there's the “revocation” of the grant :-p )