File libgcrypt-ECDSA_check_coordinates_range.patch of Package libgcrypt.13941

Overview Repositories Revisions Requests Users Attributes Meta

File libgcrypt-ECDSA_check_coordinates_range.patch of Package libgcrypt.13941

From 7b6c2afd699e889f5f054cc3d202a61bd0ee1dcf Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Werner Koch <wk@gnupg.org>
Date: Tue, 5 Jun 2018 14:33:01 +0200
Subject: [PATCH] ecc: Improve gcry_mpi_ec_curve_point
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=UTF-8
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit

* mpi/ec.c (_gcry_mpi_ec_curve_point): Check range of coordinates.
* tests/t-mpi-point.c (point_on_curve): New.
--

Due to the conversion to affine coordinates we didn't detected points
with values >= P.  The solution here might not be the best according
to the NIST standard (it is done there at an earlier opportunity) but 
it reliably detects points we do not expect to receive.

The new test vectors have been compared against gnutls/nettle.

From 6606ae44e0de1069b29dd4215ee9748280940e1b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Werner Koch <wk@gnupg.org>
Date: Tue, 5 Jun 2018 14:29:53 +0200
Subject: [PATCH] mpi: New internal function _gcry_mpi_cmpabs.

* mpi/mpi-cmp.c (_gcry_mpi_cmp): Factor out to ...
(do_mpi_cmp): New.  Add arg absmode.
(_gcry_mpi_cmpabs): New.
* src/gcrypt-int.h (mpi_cmpabs): New macro.

diff --git a/mpi/ec.c b/mpi/ec.c
index e18dcce..adb0260 100644
--- a/mpi/ec.c
+++ b/mpi/ec.c
@@ -1522,6 +1522,15 @@ _gcry_mpi_ec_curve_point (gcry_mpi_point_t point, mpi_ec_t ctx)
   y = mpi_new (0);
   w = mpi_new (0);
 
+  /* Check that the point is in range.  This needs to be done here and
+   * not after conversion to affine coordinates.  */
+  if (mpi_cmpabs (point->x, ctx->p) >= 0)
+    goto leave;
+  if (mpi_cmpabs (point->y, ctx->p) >= 0)
+    goto leave;
+  if (mpi_cmpabs (point->z, ctx->p) >= 0)
+    goto leave;
+
   switch (ctx->model)
     {
     case MPI_EC_WEIERSTRASS:
diff --git a/mpi/mpi-cmp.c b/mpi/mpi-cmp.c
index 838a7c9..66e0961 100644
--- a/mpi/mpi-cmp.c
+++ b/mpi/mpi-cmp.c
@@ -54,15 +54,19 @@ _gcry_mpi_cmp_ui (gcry_mpi_t u, unsigned long v)
 }
 
 
-int
-_gcry_mpi_cmp (gcry_mpi_t u, gcry_mpi_t v)
+/* Helper for _gcry_mpi_cmp and _gcry_mpi_cmpabs.  */
+static int
+do_mpi_cmp (gcry_mpi_t u, gcry_mpi_t v, int absmode)
 {
   mpi_size_t usize;
   mpi_size_t vsize;
+  int usign;
+  int vsign;
   int cmp;
 
   if (mpi_is_opaque (u) || mpi_is_opaque (v))
     {
+      /* We have no signan and thus ABSMODE has no efeect here.  */
       if (mpi_is_opaque (u) && !mpi_is_opaque (v))
         return -1;
       if (!mpi_is_opaque (u) && mpi_is_opaque (v))
@@ -82,26 +86,42 @@ _gcry_mpi_cmp (gcry_mpi_t u, gcry_mpi_t v)
 
       usize = u->nlimbs;
       vsize = v->nlimbs;
+      usign = absmode? 0 : u->sign;
+      vsign = absmode? 0 : v->sign;
 
       /* Compare sign bits.  */
 
-      if (!u->sign && v->sign)
+      if (!usign && vsign)
         return 1;
-      if (u->sign && !v->sign)
+      if (usign && !vsign)
         return -1;
 
       /* U and V are either both positive or both negative.  */
 
-      if (usize != vsize && !u->sign && !v->sign)
+      if (usize != vsize && !usign && !vsign)
         return usize - vsize;
-      if (usize != vsize && u->sign && v->sign)
+      if (usize != vsize && usign && vsign)
         return vsize + usize;
       if (!usize )
         return 0;
       if (!(cmp = _gcry_mpih_cmp (u->d, v->d, usize)))
         return 0;
-      if ((cmp < 0?1:0) == (u->sign?1:0))
+      if ((cmp < 0?1:0) == (usign?1:0))
         return 1;
     }
   return -1;
 }
+
+
+int
+_gcry_mpi_cmp (gcry_mpi_t u, gcry_mpi_t v)
+{
+  return do_mpi_cmp (u, v, 0);
+}
+
+/* Compare only the absolute values.  */
+int
+_gcry_mpi_cmpabs (gcry_mpi_t u, gcry_mpi_t v)
+{
+  return do_mpi_cmp (u, v, 1);
+}
diff --git a/src/gcrypt-int.h b/src/gcrypt-int.h
index ad719be..a69618c 100644
--- a/src/gcrypt-int.h
+++ b/src/gcrypt-int.h
@@ -368,6 +368,7 @@ int _gcry_mpi_is_neg (gcry_mpi_t a);
 void _gcry_mpi_neg (gcry_mpi_t w, gcry_mpi_t u);
 void _gcry_mpi_abs (gcry_mpi_t w);
 int _gcry_mpi_cmp (const gcry_mpi_t u, const gcry_mpi_t v);
+int _gcry_mpi_cmpabs (const gcry_mpi_t u, const gcry_mpi_t v);
 int _gcry_mpi_cmp_ui (const gcry_mpi_t u, unsigned long v);
 gpg_err_code_t _gcry_mpi_scan (gcry_mpi_t *ret_mpi, enum gcry_mpi_format format,
                               const void *buffer, size_t buflen,
@@ -469,6 +470,7 @@ int _gcry_mpi_get_flag (gcry_mpi_t a, enum gcry_mpi_flag flag);
 #define mpi_abs( w )           _gcry_mpi_abs( (w) )
 #define mpi_neg( w, u)         _gcry_mpi_neg( (w), (u) )
 #define mpi_cmp( u, v )        _gcry_mpi_cmp( (u), (v) )
+#define mpi_cmpabs( u, v )     _gcry_mpi_cmpabs( (u), (v) )
 #define mpi_cmp_ui( u, v )     _gcry_mpi_cmp_ui( (u), (v) )
 #define mpi_is_neg( a )        _gcry_mpi_is_neg ((a))
 
diff --git a/tests/t-mpi-point.c b/tests/t-mpi-point.c
index 1eaa08a..f2378bf 100644
--- a/tests/t-mpi-point.c
+++ b/tests/t-mpi-point.c
@@ -1045,6 +1045,271 @@ twistededwards_math (void)
 }
 
 
+/* Check the point on curve function.  */
+static void
+point_on_curve (void)
+{
+  static struct {
+    const char *curve;
+    int oncurve;      /* Point below is on the curve.  */
+    const char *qx;
+    const char *qy;
+  } t[] = {
+    {
+      "NIST P-256", 0,
+      "015B4F6775D68D4D2E2192C6B8027FC5A3D49957E453CB251155AA3FF5D3EC9974",
+      "4BC4C87B57A25E1056831208AB5B8F091142F891E9FF19F1E090B030DF1087B3"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-256", 0,
+      "D22C316E7EBE7B293BD66808E000806F0754398A5D72A4F9BBC21C26EAC0A651",
+      "3C8DB80CC3CDE5E530D040536E6A58AAB41C33FA70B30896943513FF3690132D"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-256", 0,
+      "0130F7E7BC52854CA493A0DE87DC4AB3B4343758F2B634F15B10D70DBC0A5A5291",
+      "86F9CA73C25CE86D54CB21C181AECBB52A5971334FF5040F76CAE9845ED46023"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-256", 1,
+      "14957B602C7849F28858C7407696F014BC091D6D68C449560B7A38147D6E6A9B",
+      "A8E09EFEECFE00C797A0848F38B61992D30C61FAB13021E88C8BD3545B3A6C63"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-256", 0,
+      "923DE4957241DD97780841C76294DB0D4F5DC04C3045081174764D2D32AD2D53",
+      "01B4B1A2027C02F0F520A3B01E4CE3C668BF481346A74499C5D1044A53E210B600"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-256", 1,
+      "9021DFAB8B4DAEAADA634AAA26D6E5FFDF8C0476FF5CA31606C870A1B933FB36",
+      "9AFC65EEB24E46C7B75712EF29A981CB09FAC56E2B81D3ED024748CCAB1CB77E"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-256", 0,
+      "011529F0B26DE5E0EB2DA4BFB6C149C802CB52EE479DD666553286928A4005E990",
+      "0EBC63DB2104884456DC0AA81A3F4E99D93B7AE2CD4B1489655EA9BE6289CF9E"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-256", 1,
+      "216EC5DE8CA989199D31F0DFCD381DCC9270A0785365EC3E34CA347C070A87BE",
+      "87A88897BA763509ECC1DBE28D9D37F6F4E70E3B99B1CD3C0B934D4190968A6D"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-256", 1,
+      "7ABAA44ACBC6016FDB52A6F45F6178E65CBFC35F9920D99149CA9999612CE945",
+      "88F7684BDCDA31EAFB6CAD859F8AB29B5D921D7DB2B34DF7E40CE36235F45B63"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-256", 0,
+      "E765B4272D211DD0064189B55421FB76BB3A7756364A6CB1627FAED848157A84",
+      "C13171CFFB243E06B203F0996BBDD16F52292AD11F2DA81106E9C2FD87F4FA0F"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-256", 0,
+      "EE4999DFC3A1871EE7A592BE26A09BEC9D9B561613EE9EFB6ED42F17985C9CDC",
+      "8399E967338A7A618336AF70DA67D9CAC1C19267809652F5C5183C8B129E0902"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-256", 0,
+      "F755D0CF2642A2C7FBACCC8E9E442B8B047A99C6E052B2FA5AB0544B36B4D51C",
+      "AA080F17657B6565D9A4D94BD260B54D92FEE8DC4A78C4FC9C19209933AF39B0"
+    } , {
+      "NIST P-384", 0,
+      "CBFC7DBEBF15BEAD682549757F9BBA0E3F67669DF13FCE0EBE8024B725B38B00"
+      "83EC46A8F2FF3203C5C7F8C7E722A5EF",
+      "0548FE281BEAB18FD1AB86F59B0CA524479A4A81373C83B78AFFD801FAC75922"
+      "96470753DCF46173C9AA4A8A4C2FBE51"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-384", 0,
+      "1DC8E054A883DB81EAEDE6C487B26816C927B8196780525A6CA8F675D2557752"
+      "02CE06CCBE705EA8A38AA2894D4BEEE6",
+      "010191050E867AFAA96A199FE9C591CF8B853D81486786DA889124881FB39D2F"
+      "8E0875F4C4BB1E3D0F8535C7A52306FB82"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-384", 1,
+      "2539FC368CE1D5E464B6C0FBB12D557B712327DB086975255AD7D17F7E7E4F23"
+      "D719ED4116E2CC907AEB92CF22331A60",
+      "8843FDBA742CB64323E49CEBE8DD74908CFC9C3AA0015662DFBB7219E92CF32E"
+      "9FC63F61EF19DE9B3CEA98D163ABF254"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-384", 0,
+      "0B786DACF400D43575394349EDD9F9CD145FC7EF737A3C5F69B253BE7639DB24"
+      "EC2F0CA62FF1F90B6515DE356EC2A404",
+      "225D6B2939CC7F7133F43353946A682C68DAC6BB75EE9CF6BD9A1609FA915692"
+      "72F4D3A87E88529754E109BB9B61B03B"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-384", 0,
+      "76C660C9F58CF2051F9F8B06049694AB6FE418009DE6F0A0833BC690CEC06CC2"
+      "9A440AD51C94CF5BC28817C8C6E2D302",
+      "012974E5D9E55304ED294AB6C7A3C65B663E67ABC5E6F6C0F6498B519F2F6CA1"
+      "8306976291F3ADC0B5ABA42DED376EA9A5"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-384", 0,
+      "23D758B1EDB8E12E9E707C53C131A19D9464B20EE05C99766F5ABDF9F906AD03"
+      "B958BF28B022E54E320672C4BAD4EEC0",
+      "01E9E72870C88F4C82A5AB3CC8A3398E8F006BF3EC05FFBB1EFF8AEE88020FEA"
+      "9E558E9F58ED1D324C9DCBCB4E8F2A5970"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-384", 0,
+      "D062B96D5A10F715ACF361F99262ABF0F7693A8BB60ECB1DF459CF95750E4293"
+      "18BCB9FC60499D009F949298F3F9F47B",
+      "9089C6328E4B39A73D7EE6FAE1A77E48CE354B83BBCE432082C32C8FD6784B86"
+      "CFE9C552E2E720F5DA5806503D3784CD"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-384", 0,
+      "2A951D4D6EB35C43D94866280D37365B82441BC84D62CBFF3365CAB1FD0A3E20"
+      "823CA8F84D2BBF4EA687885437DE7839",
+      "01CC7D762AFE613F7B5568BC516568A421159C40599E8D52DE10E8F9488931E1"
+      "69F3656C322DE45C4A70DC6DB9A661E599"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-384", 1,
+      "A4BAEE6CDAF3AEB69032B3FBA811707C54F5753670DA5173D891547E8CBAEEF3"
+      "89B92C9A55573A596123415FBFA26991",
+      "3241EA716583C11C71BB30AF6C5E3A6637956F17ADBBE641BAB52E8539F9FC7B"
+      "F3B04F46DBFFE08151E0F0950CC70081"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-384", 0,
+      "5C0E18B0DE3261BCBCFC7B702C2D75CF481336BFBADF420BADC616235C1966AB"
+      "4C0F876575DDEC1BDB3F3F04061C9AE4",
+      "E90C78550D1C922F1D8161D8C9C0576E29BD09CA665376FA887D13FA8DF48352"
+      "D7BBEEFB803F6CC8FC7895E47F348D33"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-384", 1,
+      "2015864CD50F0A1A50E6401F44191665C19E4AD4B4903EA9EB464E95D1070E36"
+      "F1D8325E45734D5A0FDD103F4DF6F83E",
+      "5FB3E9A5C59DD5C5262A8176CB7032A00AE33AED08485884A3E5D68D9EEB990B"
+      "F26E8D87EC175577E782AD51A6A12C02"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-384", 1,
+      "56EBF5310EEF5A5D8D001F570A18625383ECD4882B3FC738A69874E7C9D8F89C"
+      "187BECA23369DFD6C15CC0DA0629958F",
+      "C1230B349FB662CB762563DB8F9FCB32D5CCA16120681C474D67D279CCA6F6DB"
+      "73DE6AA96140B5C457B7486E06D318CE"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 0,
+      "01E4D82EE5CD6DA37080252295EFA273BBBA6952012D0120EAF131E73F1E5024"
+      "36E3324624471040030E1C345D65490ECEE9B64E03B15B6C7EB69A39C618BAFEED70",
+      "03EE3A3C88A6933B7B16016BE4CC4E3BF5EA0625CB3DB2604CDCBBD02CABBC90"
+      "8904D9DB42998F6C5101D4D4318ACFC9643C9CD641F636D1810ED86F1840EA74F3C0"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 0,
+      "01F3DFCB5433387B6B2E3F74177F4F3D7300F05E1AD49DE112630E27B1C8A437"
+      "1E742CB020E0039B5477FC897D17332034F9660B3066764EFF5FB440EB8856E782E3",
+      "02D337616C9D202DC5E290C486F5855CBD6A8470AE62CA96245834CF49257D8D"
+      "96D4041B15007650DEE668C00DDBF749054256C571F60980AC74D0DBCA7FB96C2F48"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 1,
+      "822A846606DC9E96452CAC373567A8B57D9ACA15B177F75DD7EF10C635F52CE4"
+      "EF6ABEEDB90D3F48F50A0C9015A95C955A25C45DE8413DE3BF899B6B1E62CF7CB8",
+      "0102771B5F3EC8C36838CEC04DCBC28AD1E38C37DAB0EA89B5EE92D21F7A35CE"
+      "ABC8B155EDC70154D6DFA2E77EC1D8C4A3406A6BD0ECF8F1EE2AC33A02464CB70C97"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 0,
+      "F733D48467912D1FFE46CF442F27FDD218D190E7B8A829D822DA3B6BAF9B987E"
+      "5B4BCCE34499248F59EEAF74F63ED15FF73F243C6FC3FD5E5842F6A3BA34C2022D",
+      "0281AAAD1B7EEBABEB6EC67932CB7E95717AFA3B4CF7A2DB151CD537C419C3A5"
+      "156ED9160758190B47696CDC15E81BBAD12975283907A571604DB23F702AEA4B38FF"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 0,
+      "03B1B274175AAEB5907152E5114CCAEADA28A7ADD4A2B1831C3D8302E8596489"
+      "E2C98B9B8D0CAE98C03BB11E28CE66D4736449758AF58BAFE40EF5A5FA22C9A43117",
+      "94C5951F81D544E959EDFC5DC1D5F42FE427871D4FB91A43A0B4A6BEA6B35B9E"
+      "BC5FB444C70BE4FD47B4ED16704F8C86EF019FC47C7FF2271F8B0DDEA9E2D3BCDD"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 1,
+      "F2248C318055DE37CD706D4FCAF7E7D96737A4A7B6B8067A66DCD58B6B8DFC55"
+      "90ECE67F6AA67F9C51B57E7B023075F2F42909BF47361CB6881C10F55FB7215B56",
+      "0162F735CE6A2ADA54CAF96A12D6888C02DE0A74638CF34CE39DABBACA4D651B"
+      "7E6ED1A65B551B36BAE7BE474BB6E6905ED0E33C7BA2021885027C7C6E40C5613004"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 0,
+      "9F08E97FEADCF0A391CA1EA4D97B5FE62D3B164593E12027EB967BD6E1FA841A"
+      "9831158DF164BCAD0BF3ADA96127745E25F349BDDD52EEA1654892B35960C9C023",
+      "AE2A25F5440F258AFACA6925C4C9F7AEAD3CB67153C4FACB31AC33F58B43A78C"
+      "B14F682FF726CEE2A6B6F6B481AEEB29A9B3150F02D1CFB764672BA8294C477291"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 0,
+      "01047B52014748C904980716953206A93F0D01B34CA94A997407FA93FE304F86"
+      "17BB6E402B2BB8B434C2671ECE953ABE7BADB75713CD9DF950943A33A9A19ACCDABE",
+      "7433533F098037DEA616337986887D01C5CC8DEC3DC1FDB9CDF7287EF27CC125"
+      "54FCF3A5E212DF9DAD9F8A3A7173B23FC6E15930704F3AEE1B074BDDB0ED6823E4"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 0,
+      "01C2A9EBF51592FE6589F618EAADA1697D9B2EC7CE5D48C9E80FC597642B23F1"
+      "F0EBE953449762BD3F094F57791D9850AFE98BBDA9872BE399B7BDD617860076BB03",
+      "0B822E27692F63DB8E12C59BB3CCA172B9BBF613CAE5F9D1474186E45E8B26FF"
+      "962084E1C6BE74821EDBB60941A3B75516F603719563433383812BFEA89EC14B89"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 0,
+      "99390F342C3F0D46E80C5B65C61E8AA8ACA0B6D4E1352404586364A05D8398E9"
+      "2BC71A644E8663F0A9B87D0B3ACAEE32F2AB9B321317AD23059D045EBAB91C5D93",
+      "82FCF93AE4467EB57766F2B150E736636727E7282500CD482DA70D153D195F2B"
+      "DF9B96D689A0DC1BB9137B41557A33F202F1B71840544CBEFF03072E77E4BB6F0B"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 1,
+      "018E48E80594FF5496D8CC7DF8A19D6AA18805A4EF4490038AED6A1E9AA18056"
+      "D0244A97DCF6D132C6804E3F4F369922119544B4C057D783C848FB798B48730A382C",
+      "01AF510B4F5E1C40BC9C110216D35E7C6D7A2BEE52914FC98258676288449901"
+      "F27A07EE91DF2D5D79259712906C3E18A990CBF35BCAC41A952820CE2BA8D0220080"
+    }, {
+      "NIST P-521", 1,
+      "ADCEF3539B4BC831DC0AFD173137A4426152058AFBAE06A17FCB89F4DB6E48B5"
+      "335CB88F8E4DB475A1E390E5656072F06605BFB84CBF9795B7992ECA04A8E10CA1",
+      "01BCB985AFD6404B9EDA49B6190AAA346BF7D5909CA440C0F7E505C62FAC8635"
+      "31D3EB7B2AC4DD4F4404E4B12E9D6D3C596179587F3724B1EFFF684CFDB4B21826B9"
+    }
+  };
+  gpg_error_t err;
+  int tidx;
+  const char *lastcurve = NULL;
+  gcry_ctx_t ctx = NULL;
+  gcry_mpi_t qx = NULL;
+  gcry_mpi_t qy = NULL;
+  gcry_mpi_point_t Q;
+  int oncurve;
+
+  wherestr = "point_on_curve";
+  for (tidx=0; tidx < DIM (t); tidx++)
+    {
+      if (!t[tidx].curve)
+        {
+          if (!lastcurve || !ctx)
+            die ("invalid test vectors at idx %d\n", tidx);
+        }
+      else if (!ctx || !lastcurve || strcmp (t[tidx].curve, lastcurve))
+        {
+          lastcurve = t[tidx].curve;
+          gcry_ctx_release (ctx);
+          err = gcry_mpi_ec_new (&ctx, NULL, lastcurve);
+          if (err)
+            die ("error creating context for curve %s at idx %d: %s\n",
+                 lastcurve, tidx, gpg_strerror (err));
+
+          info ("checking points on curve %s\n", lastcurve);
+        }
+
+      gcry_mpi_release (qx);
+      gcry_mpi_release (qy);
+      qx = hex2mpi (t[tidx].qx);
+      qy = hex2mpi (t[tidx].qy);
+
+      Q = gcry_mpi_point_set (NULL, qx, qy, GCRYMPI_CONST_ONE);
+      if (!Q)
+        die ("gcry_mpi_point_set(Q) failed at idx %d\n", tidx);
+
+      oncurve = gcry_mpi_ec_curve_point (Q, ctx);
+
+      if (t[tidx].oncurve && !oncurve)
+        {
+          fail ("point expected on curve but not identified as such (i=%d):\n",
+                tidx);
+          print_point ("  Q", Q);
+        }
+      else if (!t[tidx].oncurve && oncurve)
+        {
+          fail ("point not expected on curve but identified as such (i=%d):\n",
+                tidx);
+          print_point ("  Q", Q);
+        }
+      gcry_mpi_point_release (Q);
+    }
+
+  gcry_mpi_release (qx);
+  gcry_mpi_release (qy);
+  gcry_ctx_release (ctx);
+}
+
+
 int
 main (int argc, char **argv)
 {
@@ -1067,6 +1332,7 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
   context_alloc ();
   context_param ();
   basic_ec_math ();
+  point_on_curve ();
 
   /* The tests are for P-192 and ed25519 which are not supported in
      FIPS mode.  */

Places

File libgcrypt-ECDSA_check_coordinates_range.patch of Package libgcrypt.13941

Places